you're reading...
Reviews, The Snooty Ushers Christmas

56 Days, 56 Christmas Films: Day 21 – Miracle on 34th Street

So, Arthur Christmas and The Santa Clause both gave their interpretation of Father Christmas. Now it’s time for one of the best versions of Santa ever put on film.

And today it’s…

20th November, Day 21

Miracle On 34th Street (George Seaton, 1947)


A kindly old man calling himself Kris Kringle (Edmund Gwenn) takes exception to a drunk and unconvincing Santa in the annual Macy’s parade. He demands to see the person in charge, Doris Walker (Maureen O’Hara), who persuades him to replace the drunkard. Kringle is a hit, and becomes the permanent Santa for Macy’s. Doris’s thoroughly realistic daughter Susan (Natalie Wood) is taken to see Father Christmas by their neighbour Fred Gailey (John Payne), much to Doris’ annoyance. She wants her daughter to be raised to be practical and truthful, and so doesn’t want her head filling with stories and fantasies.

Walker also comes to realise that Kris Kringle really does believe that he is Father Christmas, and so sends him for a psychoanalytical evaluation. He passes with flying colours, but decides to move in with Fred, ostensibly so that he can travel to and from work easier, but also to allow him to spend more time with Susan and Doris. He sees them as a test case – if he can win them over and persuade them that he is real, then “there’s still hope”.


Kringle bringing together two fierce business rivals

While working as Santa, Kringle starts recommending shoppers go to other stores if Macy’s are too expensive. At first outraged, the store manager is inundated with thanks from grateful shoppers pledging their future loyalty because of Kringle’s actions. This leads to the management deciding to make this an official policy, which is a move then copied by rival store Gimble’s. Firstly in New York, and then nationwide, this kind man’s simple action has resulted in a more friendly and less commercial Christmas. However, the jealous company doctor (who Kringle had slighted during his test) has it out for him, and goads Kringle into hitting him with a cane. This results in Kringle being arrested and put in a medical facility, after he deliberately fails the tests because he has let down Susan. Fred will not give up on Kringle though, and takes his case to court. Can Fred persuade the city of New York – and Susan – that Kris Kringle really is Santa?


Susan and Kris Kringle

This is a truly magical film. Edmund Gwenn is brilliant as Kringle, and you can almost feel  the warmth between him and each of the other characters. He’s funny, charming, kind… I’m not sure anyone other than Richard Attenborough could possibly have be considered for the remake.

Also, for a film made in 1947 (and also when compared to the remake) this isn’t a soft, sentimental film. The film is basically about the commercialisation of Christmas, and there is a definite cynical streak to the film. Doris Walker is a divorced career woman trying to raise her daughter so she doesn’t rely on anyone but herself. The bad relationship with her ex-husband is hinted at, and O’Hara is fantastic. Payne as the kind lawyer (it is a fantasy film I guess!) is brilliant as well, and the supporting characters are all entertaining.

Overall, I give this

5 gold rings

5 Gold Rings Out of 5!

As if there was ever any doubt! Miracle on 34th Street is deservedly regarded as a classic, and it really is. A fantastic movie.

Well, that was good, so I wonder if the could remake it in and cast a film legend in the main role? We’ll find out tomorrow when I review MIRACLE ON 34TH STREET!

Until next time, stay gold, Ponyboy, stay gold. See you soonish.

that's all folks

PS Here’s my list so far

31st October, Day 1: The Nightmare Before Christmas
1st November, Day 2: Rocky IV
2nd November, Day 3: Edward Scissorhands
3rd November, Day 4: Trading Places
4th November, Day 5: Batman Returns
5th November, Day 6: Kiss Kiss Bang Bang
6th November, Day 7: Gremlins
7th November, Day 8: Eyes Wide Shut
8th November, Day 9: Love Actually
9th November, Day 10: Lethal Weapon
10th November, Day 11: Die Hard / Die Hard 2
11th November, Day 12: About A Boy
12th November, Day 13: Trapped In Paradise
13th November, Day 14: Reindeer Games
14th November, Day 15: Joyeux Noel
15th November, Day 16: Nativity / Nativity 2 / Nativity 3: Dude, Where’s My Donkey?
16th November, Day 17: Jack Frost
17th November, Day 18: Jack Frost
18th November, Day 19: Arthur Christmas
19th November, Day 20: The Santa Clause / The Santa Clause 2 / The Santa Clause 3
20th November, Day 21: Miracle On 34th Street


About Snooty Usher James

Favourite Film: This Is Spinal Tap (1984) Least Favourite Film: Probably the American version of One Missed Call (2008) Guilty Pleasure: No Holds Barred (1989) I'm the exile of the group, after living in the South for a couple of years I've now moved to Edinburgh to start the next chapter. I've got a wide ranging love of film and TV, but I am definitely the fourth usher in terms of film knowledge. I do however have a stack of DVDs to work through, and both a Netflix and an Amazon Prime subscription with which to get involved. So, even if my job means I don't get to see as many of the new releases as I would like, I hope to be able to chip in with some reviews of my own. My other hobbies include playing the guitar, trying to play the ukulele, Football Manager and Radio 4. I'm also a big fan of wrestling. Part of that means that I have a bunch of ideas for columns that I have stolen from various parts of IWC, so look out for them. But hey, enough of my yacking. What do you say.....let's boogie.



  1. Pingback: 56 Days, 56 Christmas Films: Day 22 – Miracle On 34th Street | The Snooty Ushers - November 21, 2016

  2. Pingback: 56 Days, 56 Christmas Films: Day 23 – Scrooged | The Snooty Ushers - November 22, 2016

  3. Pingback: 56 Days, 56 Christmas Films: Day 24 – Scrooge | The Snooty Ushers - November 23, 2016

  4. Pingback: 56 Days, 56 Christmas Films: Day 25 – The Muppet Christmas Carol | The Snooty Ushers - November 24, 2016

  5. Pingback: 56 Days, 56 Christmas Films: Day 25 – Elf | The Snooty Ushers - November 25, 2016

  6. Pingback: 56 Days, 56 Christmas Films: Day 27 – Home Alone / Home Alone 2 | The Snooty Ushers - November 26, 2016

  7. Pingback: 56 Days, 56 Christmas Films: Day 28 – Dr. Seuss’ How the Grinch Stole Christmas | The Snooty Ushers - November 27, 2016

  8. Pingback: 56 Days, 56 Christmas Films: Day 29 – Black Christmas | The Snooty Ushers - November 28, 2016

  9. Pingback: 56 Days, 56 Christmas Films: Day 30 – Jingle All The Way | The Snooty Ushers - November 29, 2016

  10. Pingback: The Snooty Ushers’ Round-Up: November 2016 | The Snooty Ushers - November 30, 2016

  11. Pingback: 56 Days, 56 Christmas Films: Day 31 – Rare Exports | The Snooty Ushers - November 30, 2016

  12. Pingback: 56 Days, 56 Christmas Films: Day 32 – Polar Express | The Snooty Ushers - December 1, 2016

  13. Pingback: 56 Days, 56 Christmas Films: Day 33 – A Christmas Story | The Snooty Ushers - December 2, 2016

  14. Pingback: 56 Days, 56 Christmas Films: Day 34 – Bad Santa | The Snooty Ushers - December 3, 2016

  15. Pingback: 56 Days, 56 Christmas Films: Day 35 – National Lampoon’s Christmas Vacation | The Snooty Ushers - December 4, 2016

  16. Pingback: 56 Days, 56 Christmas Films: Day 36 – Santa Claus: The Movie | The Snooty Ushers - December 5, 2016

  17. Pingback: 56 Days, 56 Christmas Films: Day 37 – Krampus | The Snooty Ushers - December 6, 2016

  18. Pingback: 56 Days, 56 Christmas Films: Day 43 – Santa’s Little Helper | The Snooty Ushers - December 12, 2016

  19. Pingback: 56 Days, 56 Christmas Films: Day 44 – Santa With Muscles | The Snooty Ushers - December 14, 2016

  20. Pingback: 56 Days, 56 Christmas Films: Day 45 – Santa’s Slay | The Snooty Ushers - December 14, 2016

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s


%d bloggers like this: