you're reading...

Doctor Who, Season 10, Episode 2: “Smile” Review

“You’re an excellent tutor”


Last week’s opening episode “The Pilot” (read my review here) had plenty of the hallmarks of the soft rebooting that comes with a new assistant. Picking straight up from that, we see The Doctor offering Bill a chance to pick where they go for her first “proper” trip. After pointing out some of the stranger parts of the TARDIS’ set up (why aren’t the chairs near the control panel?), Bill settles on a trip to the future, to see if “it all turns out ok”. 

They arrive at one of the first human settlements (slightly reminiscent of “New Earth” from David Tennant’s first trip with Rose Tyler) on another planet. A colony has been set up, but where are all of the people? Why do the robots only communicate through emoji? And do they use for compost?


Capaldi and Mackie have had two very strong episode together so far. Bill and The Doctor already have a good relationship, which I suppose is understandable: she has been going to his lectures for a long time and he has been her tutor for months. Pearl Mackie has really impressed me in the first two episodes, Bill is ready to challenge the Doctor but not in a way that feels similar to Clara or Amy. And having a character with a knowledge of science fiction, but not a total nerd, is a nice change of pace!

Also, these first two episodes have focused almost entirely on these two characters – there were only three other cast members in the opener, and after the brief opening, only the third act featured anyone outside the core pair this week – and the two actors are making the most of it. There’s some really good stuff from both of them here, with The Doctor’s smiley faced panic slowly growing through the first part of the episode.  His “not Scottish, just angry” line was a cracker, and there just one of a few lines dropped in from previous Moffat-era stories (the browser history and the great “everything that ever happened or ever will” option that Bill is given have both been used before).


Not that the episodes are dull. After the horror-fused “The Pilot”, this was more like a scifi film from the 1970s, with a supposed utopia coming across as sterile and dead. The Vardys (apparently not having a party) misunderstanding human emotion were great “villains”, the type that could turn up again in the future. Surely other ships might have had similar nanobots to terraform planets, maybe the Doctor stumbles across another one? The also reminded me of the Futurama version of Santa Claus from their various Xmas episodes (which I wrote about here), who had his niceness levels set too high and so deemed everyone (bar Zoidberg) to be naughty. And obviously the classic Twilight Zone episode “It’s a Good Life” had some influence on that chilling opening scene.

The ending even sets up next week’s episode, in an old time London with a frozen Thames and an elephant. Will they get back to Nardole before that cup of tea gets cold?

Until next time, stay gold, Ponyboy, stay gold. See you soonish.

that's all folks

Like what you’ve read? LIKE us on Facebookfollow us on Twitter, and look us up on Instagram!

About Snooty Usher James

Favourite Film: This Is Spinal Tap (1984) Least Favourite Film: Probably the American version of One Missed Call (2008) Guilty Pleasure: No Holds Barred (1989) I'm the exile of the group, after living in the South for a couple of years I've now moved to Edinburgh to start the next chapter. I've got a wide ranging love of film and TV, but I am definitely the fourth usher in terms of film knowledge. I do however have a stack of DVDs to work through, and both a Netflix and an Amazon Prime subscription with which to get involved. So, even if my job means I don't get to see as many of the new releases as I would like, I hope to be able to chip in with some reviews of my own. My other hobbies include playing the guitar, trying to play the ukulele, Football Manager and Radio 4. I'm also a big fan of wrestling. Part of that means that I have a bunch of ideas for columns that I have stolen from various parts of IWC, so look out for them. But hey, enough of my yacking. What do you say.....let's boogie.


No comments yet.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s


%d bloggers like this: